Section
27-2115 Imposition of Civil Penalty
27-2116 Enforcement of Civil Penalties, Powers of Housing Part of the Civil Court, Collection of Judgment
27-2117 Stay of Accumulation of Per Diem Penalties During Pendency of Action
Sec. 27-2115 Imposition of Civil Penalty
a. A person, who violates any law relating to housing standards, shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less, than ten dollars, nor more, than fifty dollars for each non-hazardous violation, not less, than twenty-five dollars, nor more, than one hundred dollars and ten dollars per day for each hazardous violation, fifty dollars per day for each immediately hazardous violation, occurring in a multiple dwelling containing five or fewer dwelling units from the date set for correction in the notice of violation, until the violation is corrected and not less, than fifty dollars, nor more, than one hundred fifty dollars and in addition one hundred twenty-five dollars per day for each immediately hazardous violation occurring in a multiple dwelling containing more, than five dwelling units from the date set for correction in the notice of violation, until the violation is corrected. A person willfully making a false certification of correction of a violation shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less, than fifty dollars, nor more, than two hundred fifty dollars for each violation falsely certified in addition to the other penalties herein provided.
b. The department shall serve a notice of violation upon the owner, his or her agent or other person responsible for its correction. The notice shall identify the condition constituting the violation, the provision of law applicable thereto, the department's order number, the classification of the violation according to its degree of hazard, the time for certifying the correction of such violation and the amount of the possible penalty. It shall also advise that the department will, if requested, confer with the owner or his or her representative concerning the nature and extent of the work to be done to insure compliance and the methods of financing such work. In any case, where the provisions of this section authorize the service of such notice by mail, the statement of any officer, clerk or agent of the department or of anyone authorized by the department to mail such notice of violation subscribed and affirmed by such person as true under the penalties of perjury, which describes the mailing procedure used by the department or by the department's mailing vendor or which states that these procedures were in operation during the course of mailing a particular cycle of notices of violation, shall be admitted into evidence as presumptive evidence that a regular and systematic mailing procedure is followed by the department for the mailing of its notices of violation. Where the department introduces into evidence the business records, which correspond to the various stages of the mailing of a particular cycle of notices of violation pursuant to subdivision (c) of rule forty-five hundred eighteen of the Civil Practice Law and Rules, then a presumption shall have been established that the mailing procedure was followed in the case of such cycle and that such notice of violation has been duly served.
c. The said notice of violation shall also specify the date, by which each violation shall be corrected. Such date shall be:
- ninety days from the date of mailing of the notice in the case of non-hazardous violations
- thirty days from the date of mailing of the notice in the case of hazardous violations and
- twenty-four hours in the case of immediately hazardous violations, in which case the notice shall be served by personal delivery to a person in charge of the premises or to the person last registered with the city as the owner or agent or by registered or certified mail, return receipt requested to the person in charge of the premises or to the person last registered with the department as the owner or agent, provided that where a managing agent has registered with the department, such notice shall be served on the managing agent.
Service of the notice shall be deemed completed five days from the date of mailing. The department may postpone the date, by which a violation shall be corrected upon a showing made within the time set for correction in the notice that prompt action to correct the violation has been taken, but that full correction cannot be completed within the time provided because of technical difficulties, inability to obtain necessary materials, funds or labor or inability to gain access to the dwelling unit, wherein the violation occurs or such other part of the building as may be necessary to make the required repair. In the case of immediately hazardous violations such showing must be made prior to the close of business on the next full day the department is open following the period set for correction. The department may condition such postponement upon the applicant's written agreement to correct all violations placed against the premises by the department or other appropriate governmental agency and to satisfy within an appropriate period of time, all sums owing to the department for repairs made to said premises. The department may require such other conditions as are deemed necessary to insure correction of the violations within the time set by the postponement. The department shall prepare a written statement signed and dated by the person making such decision setting forth the reasons for the postponement of the date, by which a violation shall be corrected or the reason for the denial of such application for postponement and said written statement shall be part of the record of the department.
d. On or before September first, nineteen hundred seventy-two the department shall classify all violations of the Multiple Dwelling Law, the Housing Maintenance Code and other applicable state and local laws as non-hazardous, hazardous and immediately hazardous, secure the approval thereof by the advisory council to the housing part of the Civil Court of the City of New York and publish such classification in the City Record. Such classification shall be based on the effect of the violation upon the life, health or safety of the occupants of the building and upon the public. After October first, nineteen hundred seventy-two and prior to October fifteenth, nineteen hundred seventy-two the department shall hold a public hearing on the proposed classifications. Notice of such public hearing shall be published in the City Record not less, than thirty days prior to the hearing. Within fifteen days after the conclusion of the said hearing the department shall forward to the advisory council the list with such proposed changes as it may recommend for their approval. Within ten days of the receipt of such list the advisory council shall advise the department as to which changes they have approved. The department shall thereupon within five days cause the list together with such changes as have been approved to be published once each week for two successive weeks in the City Record. Any person, who may be aggrieved as an owner or tenant, may within thirty days of such first publication seek a review of the department's action, provided that no such review shall stay the effectiveness of such list or the operation of the housing part of the Civil Court of the City of New York. Thereafter and from time to time the department may modify the list with the approval of the advisory council after publication and public hearing as provided for the original list.
e. In the event the department fails to promulgate such list as above provided or to take any step in connection therewith within the time provided, the administrative judge of the Civil Court and the judicial conference may take such action, as they deem necessary to insure the establishment of the housing part of the New York City Civil Court and its operation on April first, nineteen hundred seventy-three, as provided by law.
f.
- The notice of violation shall direct that when any violations of a particular class have been corrected, they shall be certified at one time to the department. Such certification shall be made in writing under oath by the registered owner, a registered officer or director of a corporate owner or by the registered managing agent. Such certification shall be delivered to the department and acknowledgement of receipt therefore obtained or shall be mailed to the department by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested no later, than fourteen days after the date set for correction in the case of non-hazardous and hazardous violations and no later, than five days after the date set for correction in the case of immediately hazardous violations and shall include the date, when each violation was corrected. Such certification of correction shall be supported by a sworn statement by the person, who performed the work, if performed by an employee or agent of the owner.
- A copy of such certification shall then be mailed not more, than twelve calendar days from the date of receipt of notification to any complainant by the department.
- Such violation shall be deemed corrected seventy days from the date of receipt of such certification by the department, unless the department has determined by a re-inspection made within such period that the violation still has not been corrected and has recorded such determination upon its records and has notified the person, who executed the certification by registered or certified mail to the address stated in the certification that it has been set aside and the reasons therefore, a copy of such notice shall be sent to the complainant.
- If the department does not inspect the premises after notification by the complainant that a violation has not been corrected, any tenant affected by such false certification shall have the right to apply to the court for a determination of violation as provided in subdivision h. of this section, at which time the court shall assess appropriate penalties as provided in this section for any willfully false certification it finds.
- Upon receipt of notice that the certification has been set aside the owner or his or her agent shall then have a right to apply to the court for a determination that such violation was corrected. Notice of such right shall appear on each notice that a certification has been set aside.
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, in the event an owner files with his or her certification a copy of a contract of sale or letter of commitment for a mortgage or refinancing of a mortgage covering the premises and further certifies that such sale or mortgage transaction is to occur within one hundred days of such certification, such violation shall be deemed corrected thirty days from the date of receipt of such certification by the department, unless the department has determined by re-inspection made within such period that the violation still has not been corrected, has recorded such determination upon its records and has given notice of such determination to the owner and has thereafter brought an action within thirty days to set aside such certification to impose a penalty for false certification and to collect such other penalties as have accrued, provided that in all such cases the department shall make such re-inspection.
- Failure to file such certification of compliance shall establish a prima facie case that such violation has not been corrected.
g. When there are a number of separate instances of a single condition, which violates any housing standard established by law, such separate instances shall be treated collectively as a single violation with respect to any one dwelling unit or with respect to the public area of a building, but nothing contained in this subdivision shall limit the number of violations, for which a penalty under this section may be collected with respect to each dwelling unit or the public area of a building.
h. Should the department fail to issue a notice of violation upon the request of a tenant or group of tenants within thirty days of the date of such request or if there is a notice of violation outstanding respecting the premises, in which the tenant or group of tenants resides, the tenant or any group of tenants may individually or jointly apply to the housing part for an order directing the owner and the department to appear before the court. Such order shall be issued at the discretion of the court for good cause shown and shall be served as the court may direct. If the court finds a condition constituting a violation exists, it shall direct the owner to correct the violation and upon failure to do so within the time set for certifying the correction of such violation pursuant to subdivision (c) of this section, it shall impose a penalty in accordance with subdivision (a) of this section.
i. In the event an owner fails to correct a violation within the time specified in a notice of violation sent to the owner, his or her agent or other person responsible for its correction pursuant to subdivision (b) of this section or within any additional time granted pursuant to subdivision (c) of this section and no certification of correction with respect to such violation has been filed by the owner or his or her registered managing agent in accordance with the provisions of subdivision (f) hereof, then at any time after thirty days have elapsed from the date such violation was to be corrected, any tenant or group of tenants, who requested that the violation be issued, may apply individually or jointly to the housing part for an order directing the owner and the department to appear before the court. Where the violation is hazardous or immediately hazardous, the thirty-day requirement shall be waived. Said order shall be issued by the court for good cause shown. If the court finds that the violation has not been corrected, that more, than thirty days have elapsed since the time to correct same has expired, where a violation is non-hazardous and that no certification of correction has been filed in accordance with the provisions of subdivision (f) hereof, then it shall direct the owner to correct the violation and shall assess penalties as provided in subdivision (a) of this section.
j. If a tenant seeks an order directing the owner and the department to appear before the court pursuant to subdivision (h) or (i) of this section, the court may allow service of the order by the tenant by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested.
k.
- Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a person, who violates section 27-2028, subdivision (a) of section 27-2029, section 27-2030, 27-2031 or 27-2032 of article eight of subchapter two of this chapter, shall be subject to a civil penalty of two hundred fifty dollars per day for each violation from and including the date the notice is affixed pursuant to paragraph two, until the date the violation is corrected and a person, who violates subdivision (b) of section 27-2029 of article eight of subchapter two of this chapter shall be subject to a civil penalty of twenty-five dollars per day from and including the date the notice is affixed pursuant to paragraph two, until the date the violation is corrected, but no less, than one thousand dollars. There shall be a presumption that the condition constituting a violation continues after the affixing of the notice.
- Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the department shall serve a notice upon the owner, his or her agent or other person responsible for the correction of violations by affixing such notice in a conspicuous place on the premises. The notice shall identify the condition constituting the violation, the provision of law applicable thereto, the date the violation was reported and set the penalty attendant thereto.
- Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the owner shall be responsible for the correction of all violations placed pursuant to article eight of subchapter two of this code, but in an action for civil penalties pursuant to this article may in defense or mitigation of such owner's liability for civil penalties show:
(i) that the condition, which constitutes the violation did not exist at the time the violation was placed or
(ii) that he or she began to correct the condition, which constitutes the violation promptly upon discovering it, but that full correction could not be completed expeditiously because of technical difficulties, inability to obtain necessary materials, funds or labor or inability to gain access to the dwelling unit, wherein the violation occurs or such other portion of the building as might be necessary to make the repair or
(iii) that he or she was unable to obtain a permit or license necessary to correct the violation, provided that diligent and prompt application was made therefore or
(iv) that the violation giving rise to the action was caused by the act or negligence, neglect or abuse of another not in the employ or subject to the direction of the owner.
Where the aforesaid allegations are made by way of mitigation of penalties, the owner shall show by competent proof, pertinent financial data and efforts made to obtain necessary materials, funds or labor or to gain access or to obtain a permit or license and such other evidence as the court may require. If the court finds that sufficient mitigating circumstances exist, it may remit all or part of any penalties arising from the violation, but may condition such remission upon a correction of the violation within a time period fixed by the court.l.
- Notwithstanding any other provision of law, when the department shall serve a notice of violation to correct and certify a condition that constitutes a violation of article fourteen of subchapter two of this chapter, the notice of violation shall be served within twenty days of inspection and shall specify the date, by which the violation shall be corrected, which shall be twenty-one days after service of the notice of violation and the procedure, by which the owner, for good cause shown pursuant to this subdivision, may request a postponement. Notwithstanding the foregoing, an owner, who does not correct a condition that constitutes a violation specified in subdivision (a) of section 27-2056.5 of this code within twenty-one days in accordance with subdivisions (b) or (c) of such section, shall correct such condition within the succeeding fifteen day period in accordance with the provisions of subdivision (d) of such section. The notice of violation shall be served by personal delivery to a person in charge of the premises or to the person last registered with the city as the owner or agent or by registered or certified mail, return receipt requested to the person in charge of the premises or to the person last registered with the department as the owner or agent, provided, that where a managing agent has registered with the department, such notice of violation shall be served on the managing agent. Service of the notice of violation shall be deemed completed three days from the date of mailing. Notification in a form to be determined by the department of the issuance of such violation shall be sent by regular mail to the complainant at the dwelling unit that is the subject of such notice of violation. The department may postpone the date, by which a violation shall be corrected upon a showing made within the time set for correction in the notice, that prompt action to correct the violation has been taken, but that full correction cannot be completed within the time provided because of serious technical difficulties, inability to obtain necessary materials, funds or labor, inability to gain access to the dwelling unit, wherein the violation exists or such other part of the building as may be necessary to make the required repair. Such postponement shall not exceed forty-five days from the date set for correction in the notice of violation and may not be extended by the department. The department may require such other conditions as are deemed necessary to insure correction of the violations within the time set by the postponement. The department shall provide to the owner and the complainant a written statement signed and dated by the person making the decision regarding the availability of postponement provided for in this paragraph. Such written statement shall set forth the reasons for the postponement of the date, by which a violation shall be corrected or the reason for the denial of such application for postponement. Such written statement shall be part of the record of the department.
- Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the notice of violation shall direct that the correction of each violation cited therein shall be certified to the department. Such certification shall be made in writing under oath by the registered owner, a registered officer or director of a corporate owner or by the registered managing agent. Such certification shall include a statement that the violation was corrected in compliance with section 27-2056.5 of this code. Where an owner corrects a violation in accordance with the provisions of subdivision (c) or (d) of section 27-2056.5 of this code, such certification shall include a statement that the work standards used to correct each violation complied with section 173.14 of the Health Code. All certifications shall be delivered to the department and acknowledgment of receipt therefor obtained or shall be mailed to the department by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested and no later, than five days after the date set for correction and shall include the date, when each violation was corrected. Such certification of correction shall be supported by a sworn statement by the person, who performed the work, if performed by an employee or agent of the owner. A copy of such certification shall be mailed to the complainant by the department not more, than twelve full calendar days from the date of receipt of such certification by the department. Failure to file such certification shall establish a prima facie case that such violation has not been corrected.
- Notwithstanding any other provision of law, when an owner has failed to correct a violation issued pursuant to subdivision (a) of section 27-2056.5 of this code in accordance with the provisions of subdivision (d) of section 27-2056.5 of this code, the department shall correct such violation within sixty days of the date of failure by such owner to certify correction of such violation pursuant to paragraph two of this subdivision or within sixty days of the date that the department mails a notice of invalidated certification to such owner pursuant to paragraph four of this subdivision.
- The department shall re-inspect each violation issued pursuant to subdivision (a) of section 27-2056.5 of this code, which has been certified as corrected in accordance with paragraph two of this subdivision within thirty days of receipt of such certification. Such violation shall be deemed corrected seventy days from the date of receipt of such certification by the department, unless the department has determined by re-inspection pursuant to this paragraph that the violation still has not been corrected. The department shall record such determination upon its records and shall provide a notice of invalidated certification by registered or certified mail to the registered address or to the address of the person, who executed such certification to the address stated in the certification that it has been set aside and the reasons therefore within thirty days of such determination. The department may commence an action for false certification against such owner at any time following mailing of such notice of determination.
- The time periods provided in paragraphs three and four of this subdivision for correction of a violation by the department and for re-inspection of a violation, which has been certified as corrected, shall not apply, where the department has attempted and is unable to gain access to the dwelling unit, which is the subject of such violation.
- Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a person making a false certification of correction with regard to a notice of violation issued pursuant to article fourteen of subchapter two of this chapter in addition to any other civil penalty shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less, than ten thousand dollars, nor more, than twenty-five thousand dollars for each false certification made, recoverable by the department in a civil action brought in a court of competent jurisdiction. If the person making such false certification is an employee of the owner, then such owner shall be responsible for such civil penalty. In addition, any such person making a false certification of correction shall be guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of up to one thousand dollars or imprisonment for up to one year or both.
- Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a person, who violates article fourteen of subchapter two of this chapter by failing to correct such violation in accordance with subdivisions (b) or (c) of section 27-2056.5 of this code and fails to correct such violation in accordance with subdivision (d) of such section, shall be subject to a civil penalty of two hundred fifty dollars per day for each violation to a maximum of ten thousand dollars from the initial date set for correction in the notice of violation, until the date the violation is corrected and certified to the department and in addition to any civil penalty shall, whenever appropriate, be punished under the provisions of article three of subchapter five of this code. There shall be a presumption that the condition constituting a violation continues after the service of the notice of violation. The owner shall be responsible for the correction of all violations noticed pursuant to article fourteen of subchapter two of this chapter, but in an action for civil penalties pursuant to this subdivision may in defense or mitigation of such owner's liability for civil penalties show:
(i) that the condition, which constitutes the violation, did not exist at the time the violation was noticed or
(ii) that such owner began to correct the condition, which constitutes the violation, promptly upon discovering it, but that full correction could not be completed expeditiously because of serious technical difficulties, inability to obtain necessary materials, funds or labor or inability to gain access to the dwelling unit, wherein the violation occurred or such other portion of the building as might be necessary to make the repair, provided that a postponement was obtained in accordance with paragraph one of this subdivision or
(iii) that such owner was unable to obtain a permit or license necessary to correct the violation, provided that diligent and prompt application was made therefor or
(iv) that the violation giving rise to the action was caused by the act of negligence, neglect or abuse of another not in the employ or subject to the direction of the owner, except that the owner shall be precluded from showing in defense or mitigation of such owner's liability for civil penalties evidence of any acts occurring, undertaken or performed by any predecessor in title prior to the owner taking control of the premises.
Where the aforesaid allegations are made by way of mitigation of penalties, the owner shall show by competent proof pertinent financial data and efforts made to obtain necessary materials, funds or labor or to gain access or to obtain a permit or license and such other evidence as the court may require. If the court finds that sufficient mitigating circumstances exist, it may remit all or part of any penalties arising from the violation, but may condition such remission upon a correction of the violation within a time period fixed by the court.- Notwithstanding any other provision of law, failure by the department to comply with any time period provided in article fourteen of subchapter two of this chapter relating to responsibilities of the department or with any such time period provided in this subdivision shall not render null and void any notice of violation issued by the department pursuant to such article or such subdivision and shall not provide a basis for defense or mitigation of an owner's liability for civil penalties for a violation of such article.
Sec. 27-2116 Enforcement or Civil Penalties, Powers of Housing Part of the Civil Court, Collection of Judgment
a. The department may bring an action in the housing part of the New York City Civil Court for the recovery of civil penalties together with costs and disbursements. Leave of court obtained by motion to the housing part thereof shall be required for disclosure or for a bill of particulars, except for a notice under section three thousand one hundred twenty-three of the Civil Practice Law and Rules, which shall be granted only upon a showing that such disclosure or bill of particulars is necessary to the prosecution or defense of the action. If it is so noted on the summons, any motion for disclosure or a bill of particulars must be made in writing and on notice and must be filed with the clerk with proof of service no later, than thirty days after joiner of issue.
b. The owner shall be responsible for the correction of all violations, but in an action for civil penalties may in defense or mitigation of such owner's liability for civil penalties show:
- that the violation or violations were corrected within the time specified in the notice of violation and the certificate of compliance was duly filed or
- that the violation did not exist at the time the notice of violation was served or in mitigation or remission of his or her liability for civil penalties show:
(i) that he or she began to correct the violation promptly upon receipt of the notice of violation, but that its full correction could not be completed within the time provided because of technical difficulties, inability to obtain necessary materials, funds or labor or inability to gain access to the dwelling unit, wherein the violation occurs or such other portion of the building as might be necessary to make the repair or
(ii) that he or she was unable to obtain a permit or license necessary to correct the violation, provided that diligent and prompt application was made therefor or
(iii) that the violation giving rise to the action was caused by the act or negligence, neglect or abuse of another not in the employ or subject to the direction of the defendant.
Where the aforesaid allegations are made by way of mitigation of penalties, the owner shall show by competent proof pertinent financial data and efforts made to obtain necessary materials, funds or labor or to gain access or to obtain a permit or license and such other evidence as the court may require. If the court finds that sufficient mitigating circumstances exist, it may remit all or part of any penalties arising from the violation, but may condition such remission upon a correction of the violation within a time period fixed by the court.c. A defendant in an action for civil penalties, who asserts that a violation was caused by the act, negligence, neglect or abuse of a third party, who has commenced an action against such third party and may request the court to permit consolidation of defendant's action for the reasonable cost of such correction against such third party with the pending action for penalties or if no other action is then pending against such third party, defendant may make application to implead the party alleged to have caused the act, negligence, neglect or abuse. Upon a finding that the violation in issue was caused by such third party, a judgment shall be entered against such third party in favor of the defendant for the reasonable cost of such correction.
d. When the department obtains a determination in an action under this article against an owner, judgment may be entered against the premises, which shall constitute a lien, when a transcript of such judgment is filed in the office of the county clerk in the manner prescribed for the filing of judgments and may be enforced against the premises and if such judgment remains unsatisfied for ninety days, as a levy upon the rents pursuant to section 27-2148 of article eight of this subchapter.
Sec. 27-2117 Stay of Accumulation of Per Diem Penalties During Pendency of Action
a. In any action for penalties under this article the defendant may move at any time before the trial of the case for an order to stay the further accumulation of the per diem penalty from the day the action is commenced, until the same is finally terminated by judgment or otherwise, including the time necessary for judicial review. The housing part of the Civil Court shall grant the motion, if the defendant shows to the satisfaction of the court that there is a substantial and real issue of fact or law concerning the existence of the violation charged. The court may impose such conditions on the granting of the motion as justice may require.
b. Nothing in this article shall prevent an owner from contesting the finding of a violation by the department in advance of the department's action for the collection of penalties in the housing part of the Civil Court of the City of New York or by any other means provided by law. In any such action or proceeding the court may stay the further accumulation of the per diem penalty in the same manner and under the same conditions as provided in subdivision (a) of this section.